Showing posts with label volpe. Show all posts
Showing posts with label volpe. Show all posts

Thursday, November 29, 2007

Reflection 11.27

In Tuesday's class Agata proposed a question that failed to be addressed by my classmates due to our many tangents about terrorism, drunk driving, and the like. She asked if it was feasible for the US to stop being the world police power.

In short order, no. Even if (my limited government friend) Ron Paul was elected President, there would be no way for the US to dramatically change its role in global affairs as the protectorate and revert to an isolationist path reminiscent of specific periods in American history. Besides our commitment in Iraq (which seems to be the most favored example IR students like to use next to 9.11), the US has troops in Afghanistan, South Korea, Japan, Bosnia, Kosovo, Djibouti, Egypt and nearly sixty other nations. These troops provide a variety of roles. They are involved with humanitarian endeavors, relief operations, development projects in addition to typical military efforts. If we were able to remove tens of thousands involved in "the police force" which protects people, territory, energy routes and American interests, our nation would play a dramatically different role in the international system. Its important to note that there would also be a feeling in some locations that the US was backing off their agreement to protect protect a region.

Tuesday, November 27, 2007

Halliday

According to Halliday, the development of international relations reflects the broader challenges and shifts in our society. He believes IR should be judged on the same standards of other social sciences, identifying four justifications for the field of study. It should: 1) train the mind, 2) put facts in the context of theories, 3) prepare students for working in international organization or foreign policy, and 4) provide knowledge pertinent to the resolution of contemporary issues.

My main contention with his argument for the discipline lies in his assertion that “facts on their own are dumb”. Fred Halliday believes that facts need to be organized into conceptual system and that these theories need to be taught to students. He later states that IR needs to remain substantive. In his opinion, facts are of limited utility on their own; IR should then produce theories that analyze historical processes and specific issues within them (745).

IR theories, although useful, cannot explain everything. Each school of thought possesses theories that help explain the world from their perspective- they are a lens to understand the world in which we live. Theory cannot be the answer to everything, because it does not ask all the questions. If we were to discount facts in their own right, we would never really be able to understand any event in the international system if it was not addressed by the existing theory. (For example, look at the resurgence of religion and the recent increase of terrorism by non-state actors).

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

Nandy- Charms of Indian Terrorism

When I began reading Nandy's The Discrete Charms of Indian Terrorism I began to think of the similarities between the hijackings on September 11th and the Sheik hijacking on July 5th, 1984. One account said the hijackers were all young men who jumped out of their seats, put on their yellow and blue turbans and claimed they had weapons, similar to the way Flight 93 was portrayed. As I continued to read, I soon realized that these hijackings were nothing alike.

0nce the hijackers landed the plane in Lahore, there are few linkages to the 9.11
plane hijackings. Numerous accounts state that these Sheiks began to provide baby food and milk for infants and children. At night, the hijackers served the hostages, and in the morning, the flight attendants resumed their post. Some individuals described the hijackers as kind. With the announcement that the Sheiks intended to blow up the plane, their was visible dissension among the hijackers, as some did not want to inflict violence. In the end, the hijackers let the passengers go despite Prime Minister Gandhi's rejection of their demands of ransom money, a return of captured goods from the Golden Temple and the release of captives from the army action of June '94.

The fact that the hijackers were so willing to concede still puzzles me. They were willing to go to the trouble of taking over a plane with nearly 200 hostage- and then back down without harming anyone when their demands were not met. This contradicted my conventional notions of terrorism. The author uses other examples in South East Asia to also challenge the idea and definition of terrorism.

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Reflection Class 11.15

When talking about religious resurgence today, Gabe was discussing the infeasibility of faith-based diplomacy in certain situations with the illustration of Pat Robertson and Osama Bin Laden working things out together in a room. Someone was quick to jump on this illustration saying OBL does not represent all Muslims. I sat there puzzled for a moment because there was a murmur throughout the class and a bunch of head-nods. Did the majority of the class believe that Pat Robertson represents all Christians, or even all Evangelical believers?

I think my narrative about class is ultimately less a critique about American society and the way we treat religious belief but more so a commentary on how religion is so often left out of the academic discourse. When we talk about being tolerant and open minded in a university setting, we automatically assume acceptance of non-Christian religions. To really have a serious discussion about religion in the political sphere and international arena, we are going to have to do a better job comprehending and acknowledging the role and assumptions of ALL religious backgrounds, no matter how common or unique they may be in society.

Thomas and Roy

The Beth Roy article looks at a specific case to draw some assertions regarding how conflict comes about in communities. Roy argues that individuals consciously choose to be part of communities and behave in certain manners, they choose to be identified by religious identity because of its historical and cultural meaning, and that communities see themselves in a historical context.

Thomas, in his book on the global resurgence of culture and religion, more so focuses on how culture fits in the context of modernity. I believe Roy's arguments fit in the context of Thomas' well and could be useful in furthering explaining the linkages between the evolving role of religion and culture in IR.

Thursday, November 8, 2007

Class 11.6 Reflection {Volpe, Week 11, Dialogue}

In Tuesday's class Steph discussed major ways we think of globalization in terms of the economy, technology, culture, transnational problems, and citizenship. The notions of an interconnected world market impacted by the instantaneous flow of information across state boundaries where cultural imperialism came into play was not new to me. The idea of global citizenship was, however, new . Unlike many of the other students in the class, I have never really thought of myself under the universal mentality of being a global citizen. Perhaps its the fact that I have not travelled extensively or that I personally don't have many connections outside of the U.S. In hindsight, its interesting to see how globalization has so intimately impacted each of our lives but more so to see the ways that as individuals, we are reluctant to acknowledge how it has shaped us.

Morely and Globalization {Volpe, Week 11, Substantive}

In David Morely’s chapter Boarders and Belongings he addresses the notion held by several scholars that “globalization is seen to threaten the integrity of authentic and indigenous cultures and thus to weaken the sense of cultural unity that holds a group together” (207). In my opinion, this aspect, that it has the ability to weaken cultures and ethnic groups, as at the forefront of the globalization debate today. This argument resonates strongly with Islamic fundamentalists who believe the West is polluting their culture. For a more specific example, we can look to Bin Laden’s declaration of jihad against the US due to their occupation of Saudi Arabia in 1996. It can also be seen in the way many in France have reacted to North African immigration to Paris- they view this as an indirect attack on what I would call “Frenchness” or what it means to be a French citizen.

The attack on globalization for its ability to weaken the culture ultimately highlights an underlying problem, in which globalization causes the deterioration of power and influence of the nation-state. I wish Morely had developed this argument in more detail, as I feel that this assertion really needs to be picked apart in greater detail.

Monday, November 5, 2007

NYT Article

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/05/us/05bar.html?_r=2&ref=us&oref=slogin&oref=slogin

This New York Times article addressed Ms. Alima Traore request to be granted asylum in the U.S. This woman from Mali was denied asylum on the grounds that the genitalia mutilation inflicted upon her as a child, though horrible, could not be repeated and was not a good enough reason. Her fear that her daughters would be subject to the same atrocities was also not grounds for asylum according to the panel. The physical and psychological damage from the mutilation were not grounds for a U.S. educated nurse to be granted asylum, so it made me wonder what kinds of circumstances do provide grounds for asylum?

Ms. Traore will also be forced into an arranged marriage with her first cousin upon her return to Mali. Traore does not want to return as "women have no voice... and men have all the control." This clearly reminded me of the gender-orientated theory debate within IR.

Comments on the article welcome!

Thursday, November 1, 2007

Nandy and MDGs

Ashis Nandy argues that development will not lead to an end of poverty. She suggests that the idea of a decline in poverty, real or imagine will defy economists and need its own autonomy from other issues. She argues that poverty is less cultural and more economic nowadays She argues that liberal democratic institutions insure some will always poor, and that there development-oriented reforms always lead to destitution. She supports eradicating destitution, and living with poverty.

This led me to wonder how the author feels about the UN's Millennium Development Goal to end hunger and extreme poverty. (In the nearer term, it hopes to cut the number of people in extreme poverty, less than a dollar a day, in half and cut in half the number of people suffering from hunger).

Thursday, October 25, 2007

Reflection on Class 10.25

The Gender group addressed the dichotomy between masculine and feminine qualities. What they were describing sounded like a zero some game- with the interdependence of the gender game, there is a winner and loser. Whenever someone displays more masculine traits, they are ultimately failing to display feminine traits.

On another note, they concluded that feminism demands the reconstruction of all of society. How feasible is that idea?

Wednesday, October 24, 2007

Feminism GOOOO

When I read Enloe’s Conclusion: The Personal is International I can’t read more than ten lines without wanting to tear apart the article, figuratively and literally. I was skeptical of feminist arguments prior to the reading; I believe looking at the role and position of women in international politics to be a good and important lens of analysis, but not as the preeminent explanation for why the world is the way it is. After reflecting on Enloe’s argument I came to my own conclusion; I am still not a feminist. Much like Chris, I found the arguments to be unfounded and obscure.

The “international is personal” motif makes sense as it implies that private relationships and personalities have the ability to affect foreign affairs (ie look at Bill Clinton’s new role as an “ambassador” to the world- people love his personablity, he is trying to reshap eour image aka pull support Hillary…). Enloe’s next argument then goes about saying diplomats need wives to provide them with unpaid services so they can build relationships with other diplomats. First of all, what the heck does that have to do with the previous assertion? Secondly, wives are not political pawns of their husbands. What about female diplomats- do their husbands provide unpaid services so their influential spouse can build relationships?

When have women ever been taught that international politics is too remote and complex for the female mind to comprehend? Where do we hear femininity’s values are weak and illegitimate? How and why have prominent female leaders’ decisions been twisted so that they are deemed manly? I may be an outlier, but I’m not hearing it from the academic pulpit. And I certainly don’t ACTUALLY see it playing out in the international system.

Enloe ends with saying that feminism will bring about a more realistic approach to international politics. I’m trying not to chuckle. I feel feminist theory is anything but a realistic analysis of the system.

Friday, October 19, 2007

Reflection Class 10.18

Will in the post-colonialism group presentation addressed Muppidi's belief articulated in The Politics of The Global that we are moving towards a post-colonial world order. This infers that we are not quite there yet.

I can comprehend Muppidi's assertion, but I question its value. If we have three main uses of IR theory, (critique, tool, everyday practice) how relevant is one that addresses a system that fails to exist? True, post-colonialism can shed light on the relationships between states in the future and perhaps predict explanations for states' behavior and development patterns. This theory is, however, unable to explain the current system and does not clarify day to day events.

I just find this theory to be too philosophical and abstract. I also hear dependencia rhetoric when we read/ discuss post-colonialism. I believe this theory is less causal than dependencia, but nonetheless, I still am keying into the principals that the West is modern and imposing their views and their course of development on the colonized or LDCs.

Thursday, October 18, 2007

Muppidi

Muppidi addresses Scary's notion of "object responsibilities" (282). I found this argument to be particularly interesting. The day-to-day expectations that individuals possess dramatically influence the way we act and perceive the world around us. From a political vantage point, this is evident in the way we believe objects in the colonial order to be similar to the full subjects of that order. Evaluating actors failure to meet expectations allows us greater incite into the practice in the post colonial order.

Although I appreciate Muppidi's use of the Clinton, Bush and Blair throughout the argument, I was wondering if are other Western examples that would suffice. I am curious to see this argument is actually just US-British- crentic because of our imperial role throughout the 20th century. Certainly other states had imperial roles that should be evaluated.

Thursday, October 4, 2007

Is the state a person?

I agree with Jackson's primary assertion in Is the state a person? Why should we care? The state is one of the most fundamental aspects of IR, yet there is little theorizing on the basic object of analysis. Realists, neorealists, neoliberal institutionalists and Marxists all believe states have perceptions, desires, and emotions. Constructivists either choose to lessen the importance of the state in comparison to other actors or focus on how state identity affects state action.

The state as a person needs greater analysis. If we fail to discuss and illustrate the diversity of perspectives of theorists regarding the state, we will truly be unable to have debates on other social, philosophical, and ethical issues within IR. With the state as a focal point of IR theory, we need a more in-depth discussion on the definition, role, and perceptions of the state.

Thursday, September 27, 2007

Reflection on class 9.27

Constructivism has four main focal points: history and change, state interest and its identity, anarchy being thick, and international institutions and how they help change state’s ideas about what policies they should follow. I found the notion of “anarchy being thick” to be the most interesting. Within the international system, states recognize other states’ sovereignty. Although there is no over-arching world government, sovereign states agree to behave in certain ways. This perpetuates the notion that despite the anarchic system, rules and norms do exist. This view of anarchy is a central tenant of constructivism discussed in class.

Relational Constructivism and 9.11

After reading Jackson’s Relational Constructivism: A War of Words, I thought about using relational constructivism to approach the actions taken by the U.S. government following September 11, 2001. This theory emphasizes the activities devoted to legitimizing actions; the actors give public reasons for their course of action, actors criticize all other options, and also place blame and responsibility on those with opposing views.

In hindsight, it is easy to apply this theory to the actions undertaken by the Bush administration in the post-9/11 world. Bush’s team gave reasons for attacking the Taliban in Afghanistan- they allowed a terrorist regime to hide in the mountains and prepare their next unprovoked attack against “Western” nations. The administration stressed that this military action was not an attack against Muslims but on Islamic Extremists who sought to invoke terror on the free world. News media became a pulpit; it was extensively used to convey the necessity of action. They garnered international support in order to demonstrate the international community’s support against terrorism . The administration criticized other options- if you did not support the war effort in Afghanistan, you were viewed as unpatriotic and weak for not wanting to stop extremism. Blame was placed on other regimes; it did not matter that U.S. intelligence, the FAA, the Clinton Administration, the military etc. had failed to protect American lives by preventing the attack.

Although I do not believe this theory has all the answers, I do believe that relational constructivism sheds an interesting light on IR theory. I believe that the legitimacy aspect of this perspective does play a large role in state actions.

Thursday, September 20, 2007

Haas and Regional Integration

Haas’ believes that the study of regional integration is concerned with the explanation of how and why sovereign states voluntarily merge and mix with their neighbors so they loose aspects of sovereignty, in terms of economics, politics and defense, while acquiring new techniques for conflict resolution. He also states that regional integration is concerned with the outcomes of regional cooperation. I found it very interesting that the common market was the best means for rapid regional integration. This leads to maximizing spillover across countries. “Spillover in the scope of collective action,” was a phrase use to depict the nature of integration; it was a process where actors made decisions incrementally.

Another aspect of Haas’ argument that was not something I previously considered was the common threads between the Communication and Neo-Functional approaches. They both focus on gains and losses of actors, symbolic communications between elites, expectations of elites, and adequacy of institutions to handle dialog regarding integration. These common threads helped me to remember that theories are merely a tool for understanding the larger picture. Theories are bound to overlap, as no theory will always have a unique perspective on a certain issue.

Friday, September 14, 2007

Reflection on 9.13 class

The neo-neo debate presents the points of differentiation in neoliberal and neorealist schools of thought. Although they both agree that the international system is characterized by anarchy, it appears that their disagreements greatly separate the two theories.

Neorealists believe international cooperation is unlikely to happen, whereas neoliberals believe cooperation will occur if there is mutual interest between states or actors. Absolute gains are emphasized in neorealism and relative gains are stressed in neoliberalism. Neorealists believe a state's concern for power and security are immediate factors affecting the state and neoliberals believe that issues and ideas like economic development, the environment, and the international political economy drives state behavior.

After the class discussion, it was evident that no single theory can provide all the answers. I believe that elements in both are beneficial when trying to grasp the international system and the way in which it operates. In addition, to me, these theories seem to imply a linear/ black and white answer for all issues. I think the all-encompassing nature of the theories may actually be a detriment to them-they do not often acknowledge the values-dilemma or state power-dilemma that states undertake when enacting policies.

Thursday, September 13, 2007

Doyle- Liberalism and World Politics

Week 3


Doyle evaluates three theorists who hold different views of liberalism; Schumpeter’s beliefs are in line with liberal pacifism, Machivelli’s with liberal imperialsm and Kant’s with liberal internationalism.

Schumpeter believes that capitalism and democracy lead to liberal pacifism. He argues that capitalism brings about economic rationalism and as a result, democratic capitalism leads to peace. According to Schumpeter, no democracy would pursue the minority interest, war profiteers and the elite, and tolerate the high costs associated with imperialism. Minorities like monopolists would encourage imperial expansion to gain access to more markets, but rational citizens would not allow this to be pursued. He has three main pacifist assumptions: there is no room for non-economic objectives for individuals, there is no room for non-economic objectives for states, and that world politics are homogenized.

Machievelli’s argument greatly differs from Schumpeter as he believes republics are not pacifistic. He contents that republics are actually the best mode of expansionism. Liberty associated with the free republic encourages increased population and property. He believes that citizens are all, in effect, trying to dominate others despite the facts that their goals are diverse.

Kant’s view of liberal internationalism stresses the belief that liberal states have created a peace among themselves. He believes perpetual peace will occur with a republic guided by a constitution, the formation of alliances between free states, and cosmopolitan law. Kant believes that cosmopolitan law adds material incentives to moral commitments. In his opinion, the market removes decisions of production and distribution from the realm of the state. Kant believes the interconnectedness of these characteristics will help sustain liberal peace.

I think there is merit to each argument. I believe that these arguments are not necessarily mutually exclusive; within the international system, liberalism can bring about peace, imperialism, and international agreements in different states. I can understand how capitalism and democracy can facilitate peace, but I also see how it has fostered competition and conquest, both militarily and economically.

Thursday, September 6, 2007

Grieco- Week 2 Substantive

Grieco’s critique of neoliberal institutionalism was more so a resounding stamp of approval for realism.

New liberal institutionalists argue that international institutions can help states cooperate. Neoliberal theory suggests that states with common political, economic, and military interests will be more likely to have political-economic cooperation. They agree with realists that anarchy impedes cooperation in the global system, but believe realists dramatically overemphasize conflict and the fail to give credit to institutions for their ability to promote cooperation between states. Neoliberalism suggests states seek to achieve maximum absolute gains and are indifferent to other states’ gains. They note states “cheating” in the system can potentially be a threat but contend new institutions eliminate that threat. These institutions are a stronghold of the international system. Other key actors include labor unions, interest groups, political parties, MNCs, and transgovernmental organizations.

Realists, on the other hand, believe that even among states with shared interests, the lack of a governing central authority fosters conflict and competition between states Realism, opposed to neoliberal institutionalism, does a far better job of addressing the issues of conflict and competition. According to Grieco, this means that realism is the most powerful theory of international politics.

Realists believe states are rational actors whose motives and actions are shaped by anarchy. In their point of view, states are preoccupied with the ideas of power and security. States are unwilling to cooperate because it may result in losing independence or security. Realists are also pessimistic about cooperation because they believe a state needs to focus not just on absolute gains but also maintaining a small gap in gains that are favorable for their partners. Due to the fact that realists address the uncertainties and risks of others actors, Grieco believe that realism provides a more comprehensive theory of the problem of cooperation than neoliberal institutionalism.

Although I agree with the majority of points in Grieco’s argument, I am reluctant to consider new liberal institutionalism as a void theory in international politics. The current international system and power structure encourages states to act in their own self-interest. If the costs of acting in such a manner ultimately began to dramatically hurt states, I believe states would begin to focus more on their absolute gains and less on the gap between gains from the respective partners.